MHIC No. 89306Mon–Fri, 8 am–5 pm410-916-0800

Roof renewal vs. replacement: what to weigh before you sign

Short answer: Replace a roof when it is failing: leaking, sagging or missing a lot of shingles. If the shingles are aging but still sound, renewing them with a treatment like Gonano NuRoof can extend their life for a fraction of the cost of tearing off and starting over.

Roof renewal vs. replacement: what to weigh before you sign

When a roof starts to look worn, most homeowners assume the next step is a new one. Sometimes it is. But often the shingles have years left in them, and replacing them early means paying for a roof you didn't need yet.

What a replacement involves

A full replacement means tearing off the old shingles, hauling them away, repairing any damaged decking, and installing new underlayment and shingles. It usually means a dumpster in the driveway, several days of noise, and the biggest bill of any option.

It is also the right answer when the roof is truly done. If water is getting in, the deck is soft, or large sections are missing or cracked, no treatment will fix that.

What renewal involves

Renewal leaves the shingles on the roof. With Gonano NuRoof, we prep the roof and spray on a treatment that soaks into the shingles to restore flexibility and protect them. Most homes are done in a single day.

  • Cost: a fraction of a tear-off and replacement.
  • Disruption: no tear-off, no dumpster, no nails in the lawn.
  • Waste: your old shingles stay out of the landfill.
  • Life: Gonano says NuRoof can give shingles 10 to 15 more years.

How to decide

Start with the roof's condition, not its age. If the shingles are worn but still flat and the roof isn't leaking, renewal is worth a look. If there are leaks, sagging or widespread damage, plan for repair or replacement. Our candidate checklist walks through the signs.

Questions to ask any contractor

Whichever way you go, these questions protect you:

  1. What is your MHIC license number? Maryland requires home improvement contractors to be licensed by the Maryland Home Improvement Commission, and you can look the number up. Ours is MHIC No. 89306.
  2. Will I get a written contract? Maryland home improvement contracts must include the contractor's name, address, phone number and MHIC license number.
  3. What warranty comes with the work, and is it in writing?
  4. Who will actually do the work on my roof?

Get an honest answer

We'll look at your roof and tell you which option makes sense. Call 410-916-0800 or request a quote. We work across Carroll, Howard and Baltimore counties, including Sykesville, Columbia, Clarksville and Reisterstown.

FAQ

Questions about this topic

Is roof renewal cheaper than replacement?

Yes. Renewal costs a fraction of a full tear-off and replacement because the shingles stay on the roof and most homes are done in a day.

When should I replace instead of renew?

Replace when the roof is failing: leaks, a sagging deck, or many missing, cracked or badly curled shingles. Renewal is for worn shingles that are still sound.

How do I check a contractor's license in Maryland?

Ask for their MHIC license number and look it up with the Maryland Home Improvement Commission. Licensed contractors must show the number in their advertising.

More articles

Talk to Phil about your roof

Call 410-916-0800, Mon–Fri, 8 am–5 pm, or send a quote request and we will call you back.

Call Phil: 410-916-0800